GolfinAmigos, The Mid-Atlantic Golf Home Page!
Skip Navigation Links.



Pilgrim's Oak Golf Course

The stretch of I-95 between Baltimore and Philadelphia is a common route for many commuters and salesman alike. Even though the cities are only an hour's drive apart, the small towns and suburbs between are home to a plethora of quality golf courses.

A couple of weeks ago we made a trip up I-95 to play Pilgrim's Oak Golf Course in Peach Bottom Pennsylvania. This "hidden gem" is a world away from both cities but close enough to escape and enjoy one of the most interesting and best conditioned courses anywhere!

This once sprawling dairy farm is located in Southern Lancaster County and was transformed into a golf course by designer Michael Hurdzan in 1996. It has sense been a favorite with the local golfing community and a must play for all Mid-Atlantic golf enthusiasts.

What makes the course special is its diversity; no two-holes look similar and the various mounding and rolling topography make for an ever changing round of golf.

The front nine starts with a links feel with wide-open fairways giving all golfers the ability to rebound from a wayward tee shot. At the tee diversity is ever present; there's the down-hill, up-hill and tee shot to blind fairways where you just aim and hope your shot is going in the right direction.

From the fairway you'll get more of the same with approach shots that challenge your ability to judge changes in elevation to avoid the assortment of "trouble" guarding the greens..

The most diverse characteristic of the entire course awaits you on the greens. Each putting surface at Pilgrim's Oak presents a devilishly small target with a variety of slope and "rounded" edges. Pinehurst No.2 comes to mind where even though the green looks like a manageable target, the rounded edges and slope take away a third of the outside circumference of the green.

But if that wasn't enough to challenge your golfing prowess, most of the greens have shaved collection areas where overly aggressive shots without spin go to die. Depending on pin position these collection areas can make for an "ideal" or "impossible" place to chip.

If you're lucky enough to be chipping up-hill and with the grain of the grass, you'll have a relatively easy up and down. But if your luck has run out and you're chipping against the grain to a down slope, then getting the ball back on the green to a reasonable putting distance is a test.

But don't let us sway your own opinion, for each test the course presents there's another opportunity to score. Like all great courses adversity and opportunity must be an equal balance; testing both skill and ability to manage the game. So if you think you're up for the challenge then a round at Pilgrim's Oak is a sure bet to test each club in your bag!

Amigos Favorite Hole:We had many choices for favorite at Pilgrim's Oak but we decided the 493-yard Par 5 18th was a great finishing hole.

At the tee you're presented with a risk reward hole that is reachable in two but due to dueling water hazards on both sides of the fairway I suggest playing this Par-5 with a three shot approach.

If you take the three shot approach a hybrid or 3-wood is enough ample enough club to put you in good position for your lay-up shot. The second reason for playing this hole with a three shot approach is the small green guarded by a water hazard on the right and front side of the green.

Your shot to the green must be an accurate shot. If you play conservative to avoid the water hazard and error long and to the left then you'll have one of those delicate collection area chip shots I discussed earlier.





Review Date: 10/25/2008

Course review ratings are conducted on a five point scale. ( 1 = Double Bogey 3 = Par 5 = Eagle)

Tees:
With four sets of tees ranging from 6,766 yards to 5,063 yards make sure to pick the right set of tees for your game. When I play a new course instead of judging the overall length I analyze the distance of the Par-3s and pick the tee set that won’t be to much of a struggle. It’s always a good gauge on which set of tees are best fro your game.

Even though the tees were in very good condition some seemed a bit sloped in one direction or the other. Of course this could be an optical illusion; maybe my mind was playing tricks due to the ever changing slope of the course

 
Fairways:
The wide receptive fairways were in great shape. The front nine is wide-open so even if you're spraying the ball at the start it's hard to get into to much trouble.

Make sure to practice some uneven lies while warming up because there are plenty of up and downhill lies on the course.


Rough:
The rough was in perfect shape and really only affected play off the fairways. If you end up in the thicker cut you can still get the ball out and to the green.

There isn't much rough around the greens. The setup is shaved edges with plenty of collection areas. In my mind this setup is more difficult than thick rough so make sure to leave extra time to practice these shots prior to playing your round.


Traps:
The course is dominated by bunkers but there when you do see them they are strategically positioned usually off setting a collection area on the opposite side of the green.

Conditions were wet to say the least. With many downpours the previous night some bunkers did have some standing water. Other than the bunkers every aspect of the course drained well.


Greens:
The greens at Pilgrim's Oak were in picture perfect shape. The relative small size makes these targets tough to negotiate and the shaved edges can turn a decent approach into a tough chip in a heartbeat.

The greens roll very smooth and if you pick the right line and have the confidence to knock the putt in, you should far well. But make sure the putt goes in; missing any with to much pace can turn a two putt in to three or worse quickly.

Course knowledge is paramount at Pilgrim’s Oak and it might be an understatement regarding the greens. Depending on pin placement you have to stay below the hole. If you miss in the wrong spot and have to chip, you'll find it hard to get up and down.


Amenities:
The clubhouse looks to be a renovated barn left over from the dairy farm. The building has cart storage on the lower level and the clubhouse and snack bar on the top level.

The course has a very nice range and practice area with grass tees, a chipping green with bunker and a large putting green perfectly placed on the way to the first tee.

During our weekend round there was no beverage cart on the course. I think this is on purpose because there are self-service coolers stocked with water at several tees on the course. The best part…they only charge 50 cents a bottle!


Staff Services:
The entire staff was very friendly with plenty of personal service you only get well beyond the beltway. We meet the starter on the first tee and he told us he was the owner. That's personal service you just don't see at many courses!

Pace of Play:
On an extremely foggy morning there was a delay so we didn't tee off at our exact tee time but once on the course we maneuvered as a twosome with hardly any wait.

The course has many elevation changes so it would be a tough walk if you’re a die hard walker. If it's your first trip to the course I would suggest getting a cart.


Overall Average: 4.63, Birdie Course
Outstanding Course, must play recommendation

We would like to thank Director of Golf Steven Kurtz for having us out to visit and review Pilgrim's Oak Golf Course.

CLICK HERE for additional course information...

Location: 1107 Pilgrim's Pathway, Peach Bottom PA 17536
Tee Time Phone: 717-548-3011
Course Type: Public 

*The opinions expressed in this course review are those of the individual reviewer(s) and do not reflect the editorial opinion of www.GolfinAmigos.com

  [Email Friend]     







Top Five Courses
3. Lake Presidential Golf Club (4.53) Eagle
4. Hollow Creek Golf Club (4.5) Birdie
5. Pilgrim's Oak Golf Course (4.5) Birdie
Bottom Five Courses
1. Ospreys Golf Club (1) Double Bogey
2. Gunpowder Golf Course (1) Double Bogey
3. Trotters Glen Golf Course (1) Double Bogey
4. Westpark Golf Club (1.33) Double Bogey
Top and bottom five course rankings is the “average of all ratings in 2009” with a minimum of three submissions.



 

Copyright © 2010 www.GolfinAmigos.com All Rights Reserved