GolfinAmigos, The Mid-Atlantic Golf Home Page!
Skip Navigation Links.



Carroll Valley Golf at Liberty Mountain Resort

What makes a great golf course? Is it the unique layout and challenge the course dispenses to bring the best out in your game? Or is it the surrounding scenery and views framed from the greens and tees that inspire not only your love for the game but the subtle nuisances of blending nature and golf?

Most would argue that a combination of the above two characteristics make a great golf course. And if that's the case, then the Carroll Valley Golf Course in Fairfield Pennsylvania is a one of the great.

This 1965 Ault & Clark design is a true embodiment of golf at its best. The course meanders through Carroll Valley taking the golfer on both a scenic tour guide and test of game. The wide open generous fairways beg for the driver and the testy fast greens require a delicate yet deliberate approach in course management.

Amigos Favorite Hole: This course has a few holes that vied for favorite but the one we liked best was the extremely long 584-yard Par 5 number 4.

From the tee the hole plays over a ridge that hides the green back and to the left. Running parallel and just in front of the green is "Toms Creek" providing a well placed water hazard for those willing to try and reach the green in two. Even on a long Par 5 your second shot will play downhill so for the longer hitters it is a possibility to go for the green in two.

On a day when the driver was hard to tame, the solo Amigo pushed his drive way right. But as luck would have it there is generous room to stray to the right and found the ball sitting up in the thick rough.

With a good strike of three wood the ball ran down the fairway and was within a pitching wedge to the green. But with a pitch that was not ideal, the ball landed just short of the green leaving a testy pitch to save par. But with one of his better chips of the day the ball was placed within 5 feet of the cup leaving a relatively easy putt to save par.





Review Date: 09/22/2003

Course review ratings are conducted on a five point scale. ( 1 = Double Bogey 3 = Par 5 = Eagle)

Tees:
Four levels of tees and very nicely maintained.
 
Fairways:
Wide open and friendly. Very well maintained and receptive for all games and clubs.

Rough:
Only one thick cut of rough and did punish if your shot strayed off the fairway. But with the size of the fairways, you have to really stray for the thick rough to come into play. The rough around the green was of medium length and receptive of chips.

Traps:
Excellent Traps. Perfect depth of sand for no excuse escapes. Recently raked and given the rain the previous night it shows great concern to detail by the maintenance staff.

Greens:
Most common feature is back to front slope and "wickedly fast". Every green was in very good shape with little to no sign of ware. To have any chance you must be below the hole, so remember keep your shots into the green in front of the flag. This is the perfect course for you to test of your putting abilities

Amenities:
The "Tavern on the Green" is perfect for a pre-round meal or 19th hole refreshments. Large chipping and putting green is just behind the number 1 tee for testing the green speed prior to your round. The clubhouse is well stocked with all the goodies one might have forgotten at home.

Staff Services:
One of the friendliest staffs around. Everyone was very accommodating with any request we had.

Pace of Play:
The pace was on average with minimal wait.

Overall Average: 4.53, Birdie Course
Nice Course, to play recommendation

We would like to thank Mr. Wim Pastor the Manger of the Carroll Valley Golf Resort for allowing us to visit and review the course.

CLICK HERE for additional course information...

Location: 78 Country Club Trail , Carroll Valley PA 17320
Tee Time Phone: 717-642-8252
Course Type: Resort 

*The opinions expressed in this course review are those of the individual reviewer(s) and do not reflect the editorial opinion of www.GolfinAmigos.com

  [Email Friend]     







Top Five Courses
2. Poplar Grove Golf Club (5) Eagle
Bottom Five Courses
1. Trotters Glen Golf Course (1) Double Bogey
2. Marlboro Golf Club (1) Double Bogey
3. Westpark Golf Club (1.25) Double Bogey
4. Forest Park Golf Course (1.5) Bogey
5. Gunpowder Golf Course (1.67) Bogey
Top and bottom five course rankings is the “average of all ratings in 2009” with a minimum of three submissions.



 

Copyright © 2010 www.GolfinAmigos.com All Rights Reserved